Most Reliable New Models by Segment
November 8, 2012
Reliability is one of the most important decision factors for car shoppers. That's why Consumer Report's annual reliability survey gets so much attention.
This week, CR released details on individual models with the best and worst predicted reliability. Below you'll find 3 data tables covering the Best and Worst models by Category, Best and Worst models by brand, and Vehicle segments with the best reliability.
Although this information is useful, I recommend taking it with a grain of salt. These days, new vehicles are generally reliable no matter which brand or model you go with. The differences between the best and worst models have been shrinking each year, so use this information as simply one factor in your consideration list, not your only factor.
It's important you test drive several different vehicles and see which ones suit your tastes best. Use the RydeShopper to get the best deals when you're ready to buy.
Best and Worst Models by Category
| Most reliable | Least reliable |
|---|---|
| Small sedan/hatchbacks | |
| Toyota Prius C | Ford Focus Hatchback |
| Scion xD | Volkswagen Jetta Sedan (4-cyl.) |
| Honda Fit | Ford Focus Sedan |
| Subaru Impreza Sedan | Nissan Versa Sedan |
| Mazda3 | |
| Toyota Matrix | |
| Nissan Leaf | |
| Subaru Impreza (hatch) | |
| Mini Cooper Clubman | |
| Toyota Corolla | |
| Family cars | |
| Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid | Hyundai Sonata (turbo) |
| Toyota Prius | Hyundai Sonata Hybrid |
| Toyota Camry Hybrid | Chrysler 200 Sedan |
| Toyota Camry (4-cyl.)* | |
| Upscale/luxury cars | |
| BMW 328i | Jaguar XF |
| Lexus CT 200h | Jaguar XJ |
| Lexus IS Sedan (RWD) | Dodge Charger |
| Audi A7 | Chrysler 300 (V8) |
| Infiniti G Sedan | Ford Taurus SHO |
| BMW 7 Series | |
| Buick LaCrosse (V6) | |
| Buick Verano | |
| Sporty cars/coupes & convertibles | |
| Lexus IS Convertible | Volvo C70 |
| Honda CR-Z | Volkswagen Beetle |
| Cadillac CTS Coupe | Mini Cooper S |
| Infiniti G Convertible | |
| Wagons/minivans | |
| Scion xB | Chrysler Town & Country |
| Toyota Venza (4-cyl.) | Dodge Grand Caravan |
| Mazda5 | |
| Subaru Outback (4-cyl.) | |
| Toyota Sienna (FWD) | |
| Small/compact sporty SUVs | |
| Mazda CX-5 | Mini Cooper Countryman |
| Toyota RAV4 (4-cyl.) | BMW X3 (6-cyl., turbo) |
| Mitsubishi Outlander Sport | |
| Toyota RAV4 (V6) | |
| Subaru Forester (turbo) | |
| Kia Sportage | |
| Honda CR-V | |
| Midsized SUVs | |
| Toyota FJ Cruiser | Ford Explorer (V6) |
| Toyota Highlander (V6) | Ford Edge |
| Toyota 4Runner (V6) | Dodge Journey |
| Toyota Highlander (4-cyl.) | |
| Mazda CX-9 | |
| Luxury/large SUVs | |
| Lexus RX | Lincoln MKX |
| Lexus RX Hybrid | Lincoln MKT |
| Toyota Sequoia | Ford Flex (EcoBoost) |
| Nissan Armada | |
| Volkswagen Tourareg | |
| Pickup trucks | |
| Toyota Tundra (V8, 2WD) | Ram 2500 (turbodiesel) |
| Toyota Tacoma (4-cyl., 2WD) | Ford F-250 |
| Ford F-250 (turbodiesel) | |
Best and Worst Models by Brand
| Brand | Best model | Worst model |
|---|---|---|
| Acura | Acura TSX | Acura MDX |
| Audi | A7 | S4 |
| BMW | 328i | 7 Series |
| Buick | Enclave | LaCrosse (V6) |
| Cadillac | CTS Coupe | SRX |
| Chevrolet | Volt | Corvette |
| Chrysler | 300 (V6) | 300 (V8) |
| Dodge | Durango (V6) | Charger |
| Ford | F-150 (V6) | Explorer (V6, 4WD) |
| GMC | Terrain (V6) | Sierra 2500 (turbodiesel) |
| Honda | Fit | Odyssey |
| Hyundai | Hyundai Veloster | Hyundai Sonata (turbo) |
| Infiniti | G Sedan | G Convertible |
| Jaguar | Jaguar XJ | Jaguar XF |
| Jeep | Patriot | Wrangler (4-door) |
| Kia | Sportage | Sorento (V6) |
| Lexus | CT 200h | GX |
| Lincoln | Lincoln MKS | Lincoln MKX |
| Mazda | CX-5 | 3 (SkyActive) |
| Mercedes-Benz | E-Class (V6) | E-Class convertible |
| Mini | Cooper Clubman | Cooper Countryman |
| Nissan | Leaf | Armada |
| Ram | 1500 (V8) | 2500 (turbodiesel) |
| Scion | xD | xB |
| Subaru | Impreza Sedan | Legacy (6-cyl.) |
| Toyota | Prius C | Sienna (AWD) |
| Volkswagen | Jetta SportWagen (5-cyl.) | Jetta (4-cyl.) |
| Volvo | XC70 | C70 |
Most Reliable Vehicle Segments
| Car type | Average predicted reliability score |
|---|---|
| Fuel-efficient hatchbacks | 50 |
| Wagons | 37 |
| Compact sports sedans | 25 |
| Compact pickups | 25 |
| Small SUVs | 24 |
| Small hatchbacks | 24 |
| Family cars | 14 |
| Coupes & convertibles | 4 |
| Small cars | 2 |
| Upscale compact SUVs | -1 |
| Full-sized pickups | -7 |
| Luxury cars | -7 |
| Large SUVs | -10 |
| Midsized SUVs | -11 |
| Sporty cars | -13 |
| Luxury SUVs | -16 |
| Minivans | -21 |
| Upscale cars | -26 |
My Recommendation for Car Shoppers
TrueCar No-Haggle, CarsDirect, and NADAGuides are the quickest way to see the lowest car prices in your area. These sites show you no-haggle prices from dealers closest to you - and the deals are usually really good. This should be the first step you take when negotiating your car price. Follow this up with my checklist to make sure you squeeze out every last bit of savings.- Gregg Fidan
Signup for The Weekly Newsletter
Each week, I'll keep you up-to-date on the latest car deals and news that might affect your purchase. This includes...
- Best Rebates, Incentives, and Lease Deals
- Latest Car Buying Scams and Tricks
- The Best & Worst Time to Buy a Car
- Which Cars You Should Avoid
About The Author
Gregg Fidan is the founder of RealCarTips. After being ripped off on his first car purchase, he devoted several years to figuring out the best ways to avoid scams and negotiate
the best car deals. He has written hundreds of articles on the subject of car buying and taught thousands of car shoppers how to get the best deals.
Latest Weekly Car Buying Tips
October 2021
- Top 100 Cheapest Lease Deals Oct 14, 2021
- Best Car Deals Around the Country Oct 14, 2021
- Biggest Discounts on New Cars Oct 14, 2021
- Real Prices of Midsize SUVs Oct 14, 2021
- Best Bang for Your Buck Lease Deals Oct 07, 2021
- Best Electric, Hybrid Lease Deals Oct 07, 2021
- Best 0% Finance Deals October 2021 Oct 07, 2021
- Real Prices of Compact Cars Oct 07, 2021
September 2021
- Which Cars Better to Lease or Buy Sep 30, 2021
- Worst Cars to Lease Right Now Sep 30, 2021
- Best Car Deals by Category Sep 30, 2021
- Real Prices of Midsize Cars Sep 30, 2021
- Real Prices of Large SUVs Sep 23, 2021
- New Cars You Should Wait to Buy Sep 23, 2021
- Top 100 Cheapest New Cars Sep 16, 2021
- Cars With the Largest Rebates Sep 16, 2021
- Price Comparison of Subcompact SUVs Sep 16, 2021
- Real Prices of Pickup Trucks Sep 09, 2021
- Best & Worst New Cars to Buy Now Sep 02, 2021
- The Best Labor Day 2021 Car Deals Sep 02, 2021
- Real Prices of Small Luxury SUVs Sep 02, 2021
- Largest Hidden Dealer Rebates Sep 02, 2021
I welcome your car buying questions. Email Me and I'll be glad to answer them!